David Shama's Minnesota Sports Headliners

2025 Hoops Game Failed but Gophers-Tommies Still Teases

Posted on October 14, 2025October 14, 2025 by David Shama

Niko Medved, the new Golden Gophers men’s basketball coach, will put his team on the floor for home exhibition games this Thursday and October 25 against North Dakota State and North Dakota respectively. Back in June Medved quietly offered to have his exhibition schedule include a first ever matchup with St. Thomas at that team’s new home arena.

The Tommies (after leaving Division III) have competed at the Division I level since the fall of 2021 and some basketball fans are intrigued by the idea of the state’s two Division I teams playing each other. Asked by Sports Headliners on Saturday if he would make a future offer on a game with the Tommies, Medved said: “I don’t know. We’ll see. I mean hopefully at some point we will be able to do that.”

This is the first season Division I teams can play each other in exhibition games open to the public. Medved thought it would be “cool” to play the Tommies at their new Lee and Penny Anderson Arena.

The timing wasn’t right for the Tommies, though, who may have been surprised by the proposal. St. Thomas didn’t want the first ever game in the multi-use arena to be an exhibition and had agreed for more than a year to play Army on November 8. The UST women’s team will also play against the Cadets in a historic doubleheader.

Not so subtly, talk of matching up the Minneapolis-based Gophers and St. Paul-based Tommies has gone on for years. Sports Headliners is told Richard Pitino, the Gopher coach from 2013-2021, said he would play the D-III Tommies. Ben Johson, Pitino’s successor and head coach until last March, said no to the potential rivalry game.

At Medved’s introductory news conference in March he was asked about the Tommies. The two schools haven’t played each other in men’s basketball since 1934. He expressed interest in a game then and also noted his friendship with St. Thomas head coach John Tauer.

“I really like John,” Medved said Saturday. “He’s a great guy, a great coach. So, we have a lot of respect for him and what they do.”

From a St. Thomas perspective, where might things be headed for a future meeting between the two schools whose campuses are just a long walk away from each other?

“We’ve said for four years, and we continue to say, we’d love to play the Gophers either in a …game at their place or start a home and home series,” Tauer told Sports Headliners this summer. ”We’d love to play them in a regular season game and our (future) schedule) is wide open.”

Tauer isn’t interested in playing Minnesota in a future exhibition game. Medved isn’t interested at this time in a series of games.

Medved didn’t go into a lot of details, but he said there are many factors impacting Big Ten teams like his that go into the scheduling process. (These can include timing on the calendar, prior commitments with other teams, logistics, and finances.) It’s also no secret that who you play in non-conference games, and whether you win, can make or break an invite to the NCAA Tournament and March Madness. Medved acknowledged you schedule to make the tournament.

The Tommies, who won a Division III title under Tauer in 2016, are the preseason favorite in the Summit League poll to win the conference championship. Last winter the Tommies came within one victory of winning the league’s postseason title. This is the first season the Tommies will be eligible for the NCAA Tournament.

The Gophers are forecast to finish near the bottom of the 18-team Big Ten. Medved is rebuilding after Johnson’s last team missed the NCAA Tournament for a fourth consecutive year.

While the novice fan is intrigued by a Gophers-Tommies matchup, there is much more upside for St. Thomas. A mid-major program, the Tommies could flaunt their resume (including with state recruits) with a win over a team from the Power Four and prestigious Big Ten Conference.

Possible scenarios from a matchup could look like this:

A blow-out Minnesota win? The public conclusion: “What do you expect from a Big Ten team playing at home?”

A narrow Gopher victory? “See the Tommies could have won. They’re just as good as Minnesota.”

A St. Thomas triumph? “The Gophers can’t even beat a good mid-major program.”

It’s well-known among college basketball programs the Tommies are a risky booking and light years from being labeled a patsy by anyone. No Big Ten team is scheduling them this season or has any recent history with St. Thomas. The analytics and intuition tell Big Ten and other schedule makers not to play the Tommies who have talent starting with the head coach who is among the best in the country.

None of this is to say the Gophers are ducking the Tommies. A game at some point appears likely. Medved believes a matchup is a “great way to get everybody talking about local basketball.”

With a season tickets base expected to be similar in size to the 5,500-basketball capacity of the St. Thomas arena, the Gophers likely will play host to the first matchup in 14,625 seat Williams Arena. It’s believed the Tommies, who are challenged to find nonconference road games against prominent foes, would receive about a $100,000 guarantee to play at Williams Arena. The game could generate 2,500 to 5,000 additional single game ticket sales than normal for a home Minnesota nonleague game.

Gopher players, not having to be concerned about anything but competing against opponents, might welcome facing their neighbors. A small sampling of players last week was favorable about a UST game.

“I would love to play St. Thomas,” said B.J. Omot …”We’ll see who really runs the cities. So that would be pretty cool to play them.”

Guard Isaac Asuma is intrigued, too. “I think it’s slowly getting put into motion, so I am ready for it.”

A third native Minnesotan and Gopher, Grayson Grove, is on board. “That’d be really fun. I know a bunch of the St. Thomas guys. Good friends with a bunch of them, so I think it would be really fun to play against them.”

Gophers Notes

Medved’s team, which opens the regular season at home November 3 against Gardner- Webb, allowed fans into Williams Arena last Saturday to watch an intrasquad scrimmage. The team looked well drilled on fundamentals and effort was apparent.

Playing in front of fans may have prompted nervousness. Neither the maroon nor gold team scored until almost five minutes had elapsed. North Carolina transfer Cade Tyson’s two free throws took the goose eggs off the scoreboard.

Tyson played sparingly at Carolina last season after he transferred from Belmont where he averaged 15 points in 61 games. He told Sports Headliners last Friday his confidence “definitely took a hit” at Carolina where he played eight minutes per game.

Tyson, a 6-foot-7 guard-forward who could be the team’s best three-point shooter and scorer, said he’s “grateful” for lessons learned last year after a 2023-2024 season at Belmont where he was second in the nation in three-point conversion percentage at 46.5.

“I feel really good about my shot right now,” he said. “Honestly, I feel like I feel better about my shot when I am not thinking about it, too much. …Just let me go.”

Tyson is one of several mid-level transfers who are part of an almost totally new Gophers roster from last season. Another is Davidson transfer and forward Bobby Durkin who was asked about the low season expectations for Minnesota in the standings.

“I try not to think too much about that,” Durkin said. “Obviously, I saw it (the Big Ten media poll) and I think we’re not too worried about what that says. I think we have the belief in ourselves that if we can become the best that we’re able to, that we’ll have a great season.”

1 comment

Impatience with McCarthy by Fans, Media Wrong Approach

Posted on October 12, 2025October 12, 2025 by David Shama

The status of Vikings second-year quarterback J.J. McCarthy is an obsession with fans and some media. Correction: it’s even more fanatical than that.

The questions are ongoing. They could be rattled off at the nearest sports bar or your neighbor’s garage:

When will McCarthy play again?

Will coach Kevin O’Connell make him the starter, or will he stay with veteran Carson Wentz?

Is McCarthy ready to perform this fall at a high level after struggling in the first two games of the season?

Will he fulfill the dreams of fans to become the franchise quarterback for the next decade?

How significant still is the ankle sprain McCarthy suffered in the second game of the season against the Falcons?

Whoa. Slow down.

Folks want all the answers right now about the 22-year-old. Understandable in the win now world of fans and the reactionary approach to the latest circumstances on the field or off.

But take a deep breath.

What the unproven McCarthy does or doesn’t accomplish this season won’t be the final chapter of his NFL life. He could play at a high level in 2025, or mediocre, or bomb out.

However, there will be more chapters in his football story.

To elaborate on that point, look at the history of three quarterbacks who were in O’Connell’s gun sights in the last 10 months. Neither Sam Darnold, Daniel Jones or Aaron Rodgers had sustained immediate success in the NFL.

The Vikings experienced a 14-3 season in 2024, with much of the success because of the career best performance by Darnold who had been a journeyman quarterback. Behind Darnold on the quarterback depth chart late in the season was Jones who had failed in his tenure with the Giants and was released by that club. The Vikings also had offseason interest in Rodgers who long ago was eased into the NFL before he ever became a starter.

Darnold was unsuccessful during six prior seasons with other NFL teams before he joined the Vikings. He resurrected his career in his first and only season with the Vikings. The Sporting News and Professional Football Writers Association of America both named him league Comeback Player of the Year for his 2024 performance that included career highs in several passing categories. Now with the Seahawks, he is among the league’s passing leaders with a rating of 114.8.

O’Connell found Jones an intriguing talent. But Jones decided during the last offseason to accept an offer from the Colts where he won the starter competition from Anthony Richardson. Jones’ time so far in Indy has been head turning for both him and the team. He has an impressive career best rating of 105.1 and the Colts are off to a surprising 4-1 start to the season. He has credited his brief time with the Vikings helping to improve his performance.

Rodgers, 41, has contributed significantly to a 3-1 start by the Steelers. The future Hall of Famer is with his third NFL team now having spent most of his career with the Packers. The Green Bay quarterback development formula is not to rush quarterbacks. Rodgers sat behind Hall of Famer Brett Favre for three seasons before starting. The Packers used the same approach with now starter Jordan Love who watched and learned from Rodgers for three seasons.

Darnold and Rodgers would have commanded sizeable contracts to play for the Vikings. Jones’ deal at a reported $14 million is a lot more than the Vikings are paying McCarthy and Wentz. It’s also less than Darnold would have wanted to stay here, and perhaps comparable to a Rodgers Vikings contract. Not sinking a lot of money into the quarterback payroll has allowed the Vikings to spend more on other positions in the last offseason.

Those assets, including in the offensive line, resulted in high expectations for the team and McCarthy going into the season. But O’Connell and GM Kwesi-Adofo Mensah have gambled they can win now with McCarthy, rather than employing Darnold, Jones or Rodgers.

Regardless of final results this season, no one should issue a verdict that pretends to know whether McCarthy can find success in the NFL. That answer can only come over time and requires waiting with patience.

Baseball Notes

A valued Sports Headliners source, knowledgeable about MLB, believes David Ross is the best choice to succeed Rocco Baldelli as Twins’ manager. Ross managed the Cubs from 2020 to 2023 with a highlight being a Central Division title in 2020.

The source said Ross has a “terrific baseball IQ.” He also said the former big league catcher is skilled at developing young talent.

Ross, who has made it known he wants to manage again, played for legendary manager Joe Maddon with the Cubs and has worked as a baseball analyst for ESPN. The 48-year-old’s media experience would be an extra bonus to his hire by the Twins.

It’s suggested that the Twins hire a manager and assemble a staff with proven skills in helping players achieve and maintain success. Find teachers who excel at knowing fundamentals, communication, and motivation. This approach makes sense because the Twins have intriguing prospects, are in a rebuild, and have a history of seeing young talent flame out.

The source mentioned above endorsed the firing of Baldelli, believing the skipper had “lost control” of the pitching staff. His view is the starters thought Baldelli didn’t have confidence in them.

The source is also not an admirer of Derek Falvey being president of both the Twins business and baseball operations. “It’s too hard,” he said about trying to do both jobs.

Here’s a list of recent Twins alumni now playing for teams who qualified for the 2025 postseason: Toronto: Louie Varland; Seattle: Mitch Garver and Jorge Polanco; Philadelphia: Jhoan Duran, Max Kepler and Harrison Bader; Los Angeles Dodgers: Ben Rortvedt; Chicago Cubs: Caleb Thielbar; San Diego: Luis Arraez.

Minneapolis-based attorney and local sports historian Marshall Tanick reminded Twins fans last week that on October 6 it was 60 years prior that Sandy Koufax, the best pitcher in baseball, sat out Game One of the World Series against the Twins because of Yom Kippur. A Brooklyn-born Jew, the Hall of Fame lefty was excused by the Dodgers in observance of the Jewish Day of Atonement in 1965. Don Drysdale started instead, with the Twins winning the game 8-2.

Koufax started Game Two but was the losing pitcher in another Twins win. The Dodgers, though, went on to win the World Series in seven games, with Koufax shutting out Minnesota in the finale. See Tanick’s article in the Minneapolis Times, https://minneapolistimes.com/60-years-ago-baseballs-sandy-koufax-made-history-here/

Isaac Asuma, the sophomore from Cherry, Minnesota who figures to be a key contributor to the Golden Gophers basketball team this season, told Sports Headliners his brother Noah is steadfast in his commitment to play baseball at the U. A future shortstop, the Cherry High School senior has drawn interest from pro scouts.

Comments Welcome

Glen Mason Speaks Out about Honoring U Football Players

Posted on October 7, 2025October 7, 2025 by David Shama

It’s Homecoming Week at the University of Minnesota where events lead up to Saturday night’s football game against Purdue. Inside Huntington Bank Stadium the names of five all-time great Minnesota players are prominently displayed for alums and other fans to see.

The more knowledgeable patrons know the famous five have their numbers and jerseys retired—Bobby Bell, Paul Giel, Bronko Nagurski, Bruce Smith and Sandy Stephens. All are deceased except for Bell who plans to attend the Homecoming game and participate in recognition of the 65^th anniversary of the 1960 national championship team.

Bell’s last season at Minnesota was 1962 when he was the Outland Trophy winner and was named an All-American tackle for a second consecutive season. Giel’s last season was 1953, Nagurski’s 1929, Smith’s 1941 and Stephens 1961.

With its rich football history, the athletic department has an opportunity to soon add to the recognition of the greatest ever football Gophers. Greg Eslinger, the superlative 2004 and 2005 All-American center who blocked for some of the best running attacks in school history, will be inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in December and is deserving of a spot at the Bank.

Glen Mason, Eslinger’s coach, said it’s overdue to retire the number and jersey of the 2005 Outland Trophy and Rimington Trophy winner. Mason told Sports Headliners “I can’t understand” why Eslinger isn’t keeping company with Bell, Giel, Nagurski, Smith and Stephens.

Mason describes Eslinger’s absence as a “pet peeve.”

Eslinger (No. 61) photo courtesy of University of Minnesota

Eslinger’s resume is eye-popping and includes being the 2005 Big Ten Offensive Lineman of the Year (only Gopher ever honored). He was named All-Big Ten three times in his career, and he was awarded the 2006 Big Ten Medal of Honor (the conference’s oldest and most prestigious award). He was also a two-time Academic All-American.

Two other players who Mason coached deserve consideration for having their numbers and jerseys retired. Tyrone Carter won the 1999 Jim Thorpe Award and was a two-time All-American safety. Matt Spaeth won the 2006 John Mackey Award as an All-American tight end that year.

“Why those guys’ names (Eslinger, Carter and Spaeth) wouldn’t be up there is mind boggling to me,” Mason said. “You know, the players’ names that were there up were great players but none better than these guys…and these (five) guys are ancient. Nobody knows who they are. It’s stupidity.”

Mason added “another thorn in my side” is that Spaeth isn’t in the M Club Hall of Fame for Gopher athletes. Spaeth, a two-time All-Big Ten selection who holds the school career record for tight ends of 1,293 receiving yards, was a four-year starter for Mason.

“Outrageous, because I could name a few guys that you could say, what are they doing in there? He’s not in there, it’s embarrassing,” Mason said.

Asked about plans to expand the number of retired numbers and jerseys, an athletic department spokesman said via text “we are continually engaged in conversations about how best to recognize and honor the contributions former football players have made to the program.”

The department will honor Eslinger at the home Nebraska game on October 17. The Gophers also plan to have representation at Eslinger’s induction into the Hall of Fame in Las Vegas in December.

The National Football Foundation sponsors the Hall of Fame which is located in Atlanta. Tickets are available at https://NFF2025.givesmart.com.

Eslinger will join 32 other former Gophers players and coaches in the Hall of Fame, including Bell, Giel, Nagurski, Smith and Stephens. Here are brief capsules on the five and what made them so special.

Bell could have been a great player at multiple positions, perhaps even quarterback. He settled for terrorizing opposing offenses as a defensive tackle on national title and Rose Bowl teams that went 22-6-1 from 1960-1962. To this day, there are Gopher historians who maintain the superbly athletic and instinctual Bell is the greatest football player ever at Minnesota.

Giel was an elusive single-wing tailback who was an All-American in 1952 and 1953. Despite playing on mediocre teams, he finished third in Heisman Trophy balloting in 1952 and second in 1953 when he lost in a controversial vote to Notre Dame’s Johnny Lattner. United Press International, though, named him College Player of the Year. He twice won the Chicago Tribune’s Silver Football Award as the Big Ten’s Most Valuable Player.

Nagurski is one of the most famous names in college football lore. In the late 1920s he played tackle, fullback, defensive and offensive end, linebacker and even quarterback. A beast whose strength was way ahead of his day, he was named a consensus All-American in 1929 at two positions, tackle and fullback. Sports Illustrated named him college football’s best player of the first half of the 20th century.

Smith, also a great tailback in the single-wing, was a back-to-back All-American on Minnesota’s 1940 and 1941 national championship teams. Those teams were undefeated and in the 1940 season he scored three game winning touchdowns. He is also Minnesota’s only Heisman Trophy winner, being honored in 1941. And, oh yeah, Hollywood made a move about him: “Smith of Minnesota.” He was one of the stars, of course.

Stephens finished fourth in the Heisman Trophy balloting after his senior season of 1961. Quite a feat for an African American who was a pioneer at the position. He was the starter on the 1960 national championship team, but his play went to another level in 1961when he made numerous first team All-American teams and was named the Chicago Tribune’s Silver Football Award winner as the Big Ten’s Most Valuable Player. He led the Gophers to a 21-3 win over UCLA in the 1962 Rose Bowl.

3 comments