It’s too obvious to ignore now. Young men who learned how to play football at Minnesota high schools are making regional and national headlines at the college level.
Twenty years ago such players didn’t command as much attention but it’s different now. Last Saturday ESPN College GameDay was in Fargo to pay homage to the North Dakota State Bison. All that program has done is use savvy coaching and a Minnesota-heavy roster to win the last two Football Championship Subdivision national titles.
The Bison roster this fall lists 35 Minnesotans. They and their teammates found glory a few weeks ago in Manhattan, Kansas defeating defending Big 12 champion Kansas State. No one should have been stunned since the Bison have defeated two other Bowl Championship Series schools since 2010 — Kansas and Minnesota. (BCS replaced the Division I-A label awhile ago and FCS replaced the smaller school Division I-AA title).
But the Bison weren’t the only showcase for Minnesota high school alums last Saturday. Former Eagan High School running back Zach Zenner ran for two first quarter touchdowns in Lincoln against Nebraska as the Jackrabbits took an early 17-14 lead. Zenner, a junior, led all FCS players in rushing last season and is No. 1 again this fall with 742 yards. He is one of 18 Minnesotans on the Jackrabbits’ roster, a team that is among the best in the FCS.
Scan the Division II top 25 coaches poll and there is Minnesota State-Mankato ranked No. 2 in the country. UMD is No. 13 and St. Cloud State No. 20 in the poll. The Mavericks have 23 Minnesotans on the roster while UMD has 60 and St. Cloud 48.
Pollsters obviously aren’t hesitant to rank Minnesota colleges high in the Division II poll. Why should they be after UMD won national championship games in 2008 and 2010? The coach of those teams, Bob Nielsen, is now in his first season coaching Western Illinois and he won’t surprise anyone if he recruits at Minnesota high schools.
St. Thomas has been in the mix for a Division III national championship the last couple of years. This summer the Tommies started the season ranked No. 2 in the country in the Division III coaches poll and despite a loss to Saint John’s last Saturday St. Thomas will remain a 2013 national power. The Tommies, who had won 36 consecutive regular season games, have 87 Minnesotans on the roster.
Minnesota colleges have loaded up their football programs with alums of state high schools. The nine MIAC schools playing football—all located in Minnesota—have 680 Minnesotans on their rosters. The 16-member Northern Sun Conference, with nearly all Minnesota-based schools, has 427 Minnesotans.
North Dakota, a member of the Big Sky Conference, has 24 alums of Minnesota high schools. Northern Iowa, from the Missouri Valley Conference like North Dakota State, has nine Minnesotans. The Panthers defeated Iowa State of the Big 12 Conference earlier this year.
It’s a nice success story for Minnesota prep football but the script grows weaker when searching the rosters of NFL teams and major college programs. Only a dozen Minnesotans are in the NFL with the most prominent names being wide receivers Larry Fitzgerald and Eric Decker.
No major program from the power conferences turns to this state’s talent pool for most of its needs. And that starts with the Gophers. On last week’s depth chart prior to Minnesota’s final nonconference game against San Jose State, the Gophers had seven state natives starting on offense and one on defense. The Gophers have 42 Minnesotans on their roster of 120 total players.
Many of the 42 will never be starters or major game day contributors. Some aren’t even scholarship players. The Gophers 2013 recruiting class had only one scholarship player from the state, linebacker Chris Wipson from Wayzata, according to Rivals.com. The year before the total was nine of 27 recruits from Minnesota.
But with so much success by other football programs — led by the North Dakota State bandwagon — are the Gophers missing the boat? Well, probably not. For openers, the Bison likely couldn’t win a lot of games week after week if they had to go against the speed, skill and depth of teams from major college programs.
Those programs recruit in talent rich states with more population and favorable climate. Generally speaking, former Minnesota preps are going to do better competing at the FCS, Division II and III levels.
“I think there’s a lot of solid high school football players in Minnesota but I don’t think there’s your elite level football players,” said Minnesota-based recruiting authority Zach Johnson. “I don’t think you can say Minnesota has the quality at the elite level that you would find in Texas, California, Florida (and) most of the southeast.”
Johnson tracks the Gophers recruiting classes and believes the program is correct in often conservatively targeting the number of Minnesotans for scholarships. “Yeah, they’re looking for a different football player,” he said. “They’re looking for a football player that can play at the highest level.”
Gophers coach Jerry Kill said “we’re doing the best we can” in recruiting state players. He believes the number of prospects who interest him as potential scholarship players can vary from five to 25. Having lived in Kansas, a state somewhat similar to Minnesota in population, Kill saw the importance of a large talent pool. “It has to do with population more than anything. More football programs, more schools, more players.”
The Gophers shouldn’t be second-guessed too much for losing to the Bison (Minnesota was rebuilding in its first season under Kill), or because of all the Minnesota natives on the rosters of teams from the Dakotas. “Minnesota is a perfect place for South Dakota schools and North Dakota schools to recruit because it’s loaded with a big metro area with a lot of football players that are just a step below what you need at the big time SEC, ACC level,” Johnson said. “You don’t see 31 Minnesota kids on a SEC roster or an ACC roster. How many Minnesota kids do you see playing in the Pac-12 and SEC and ACC and schools like that?”
Not many is the answer and that’s no surprise to even a Minnesota high school booster like Ron Stolski. He has been coaching high school teams in the state for 52 years and is executive director of the Minnesota High School Football Coaches Association.
He said states like California, Florida and Texas have special athletes blessed with speed and football is “king,” indicating the importance of the sport in those places. But that doesn’t mean Minnesota kids don’t receive top level coaching. “Our kids are as well coached as any in the country,” he said. “The feedback we get constantly is how in tune our coaches are.”
The success of the FCS, Division II and Division III programs in the region also doesn’t surprise Stolski who has sent many of his former players to those types of schools but only three to Division I football during more than a half century of coaching in Minnesota. “Remember they’re also playing schools with Minnesota kids on them. I think the coaching staffs of all those schools…are outstanding. They get that borderline Division I, Division II athlete. They coach the snot out of them.”
That “borderline athlete” is the kind of prospect the Gophers want to have join the program without a scholarship. Kill will tell you the success of his walk-on program will be critical to whether he turns the Gophers into one of the Big Ten Conference’s better teams.
And, of course, he wants the best Minnesota high school players in the worst way. That list could start with Cretin-Derham Hall defensive end Jashon Cornell, rated by ESPN as the No. 1 football player in the country for the class of 2015. Cornell and his teammates were the feature high school game on ESPN a few weeks ago.
That’s heady stuff and the kind of thing that makes someone like Rochester, Minnesota native and former Gopher Darrell Thompson feel good about this state’s prep football players. He thinks major college programs, including the Gophers, have overlooked the quality and depth of the state’s recruiting pool.
“This (Gophers) coaching staff doesn’t realize that there is more here (prospects) than people (think),” Thompson said. “The grass always looks greener. Just like someone’s wife always looks cuter than your wife or some girl. Someone else always looks better.”
Thompson believes the Gophers could typically take 12 to 15 Minnesotans for a recruiting class and be the better for it. “I wouldn’t think you’d have to go with 25 or 30 kids coming from somewhere else every year.”
Maybe the Gophers could pull that off if they could annually lock up each of the state’s best prep players. Bringing the Cornells, Fitzgeralds and Michael Floyds to Dinkytown each year would be precedent setting in this century.
Probably won’t happen but Minnesotans can know there are a lot of success stories on all levels of college football because of contributions made by this state’s high school football alums. “Our football is being played at a very high level,” Stolski said.
Comments Welcome