“Is McNabb done?”

That was the TV headline on Fox’s national pregame show about 30 minutes before Donovan McNabb and the Vikings took the field last week to play the Bucs at Mall of America Field. The 34-year-old quarterback had been a lightning rod for criticism following the September 11 opening loss to the Chargers, throwing for only 39 yards.

The Profootballtalk website headlined this story: “McNabb a major disappointment in Vikings debut.”  The article said he “deserves most of the blame for the Vikings’ 24-17 loss to the Chargers.”

Because McNabb plays the most visible position on the team he’s obviously an easy target for media and fan criticism.  McNabb had better stats last Sunday, completing 18 of 30 passes for 228 passes, but he threw no touchdown passes and the Vikings lost another game, 24-20 to the Bucs.  That made him a subject for criticism by fans following the Vikings second consecutive regular season loss.

Former Vikings assistant coach Dean Dalton, who now hosts an NFL show on Sirius XM, was asked if McNabb, a 13-year veteran with his third pro team, is still effective.  “Absolutely.  I think he’s got a lot of good football left in him,” Dalton said.

Dalton said McNabb is a “great athlete” but admitted that at McNabb’s age there is a surprising element about him.  “One thing I didn’t think he had was as much juice in his legs,” Dalton said.  “I knew he was a powerful thrower and a savvy quarterback.”

McNabb, who has rushed for 44 yards in two games, looked better last week passing, particularly in the first half, when the Vikings dominated possession time and offensive coordinator Bill Musgrave had the Bucs off balance with his play selection.   No, McNabb isn’t an NFL elite quarterback anymore but has enough physical skills and experience to help the Vikings win games.

Yes, a more dynamic playmaker could consistently lift the team beyond what it’s otherwise capable of doing.  But McNabb can still make a lot of plays, and with two quarterbacks behind him on the roster with almost no NFL experience, he’s the best the Vikings have for now.

Comments Welcome

All-time Gophers career rushing yards leader Darrell Thompson likes Minnesota redshirt freshman running back Donnell Kirkwood “a lot” and told Sports Headliners the 5-10, 215 pound Delray Beach, Florida native is probably the school’s most physical runner since Marion Barber III.

Kirkwood made his 2011 running back debut last week against Miami (Ohio), gaining 55 yards on 13 carries.  His bullish running style is a welcome addition to a team that has struggled in short yardage situations, including near the goal line.

Gophers coach Jerry Kill said Kirkwood “ran over a couple of safeties” in the Miami game.  “He’s a deliberate runner that doesn’t think about going around people,” Thompson said.  “He goes over them.”

Kirkwood played in four games last season but was granted a medical hardship waiver, meaning that starting this season he has four years of remaining eligibility.  He carried the ball 27 times for 112 yards last season.

In the Miami game Kirkwood had six more carries than Minnesota’s starting running back Duane Bennett, apparently an indication of the opportunity Kill and offensive coordinator Matt Limegrover want to provide Kirkwood.

Thompson, who provides color commentary on the Gophers radio network, said Kirkwood’s potential is “high” but like any inexperienced back it will take time for him to learn and mature.  Still, Thompson is intrigued about how Kirkwood can help the offense, including in those goal line situations with his power running.

“It’s a big deal to have a back you can give the ball to (near the goal line),” Thompson said.

Comments Welcome

Pioneer Press columnist Charley Walters had a big league career lasting less than two months with the Twins in 1969.  A change in major league baseball pension policy now includes players with minimal playing time so recently Walters received a check for $540 that he plans to frame.  He and other players who previously hadn’t been part of MLB’s pension program will receive annual checks in future years.

When Mariano Rivera broke Trevor Hoffman’s career major league saves record this week it prompted some thought about an all-time baseball team.  Here’s an offering: Rivera as the closer, Sandy Koufax starting pitcher, Johnny Bench catching, Lou Gehrig first base, Rogers Hornsby second base, Cal Ripken shortstop, Mike Schmidt third base, Babe Ruth right field, Willie Mays center field and Ted Williams left field.

White Sox catcher A.J. Pierzynski, a former Twin, was voted the “meanest player in baseball” in a major league baseball players poll, according to the September 19 issue of Sports Illustrated.  In another poll, ex-Twin Jim Thome, now with Cleveland, was voted MLB’s nicest player, according to the magazine.

The three leading rushers per game in the Big Ten are quarterbacks, Michigan’s Denard Robinson (153), Nebraska’s Taylor Martinez (128) and Minnesota’s MarQueis Gray (109.33).  Those averages place them third, eighth and 23^rd among NCAA leading rushers.

The North Dakota State team the Gophers play tomorrow night at TCF Bank Stadium is 2-0 and ranked No. 12 nationally in the FCS coaches poll.   Minnesota is 7-1 all-time against North Dakota State but lost to the Bison in 2007 and needed to block a field goal in 2006 to win.  The Bison roster is loaded with Minnesota natives and Gophers coach Jerry Kill expects North Dakota State to “play their best game” tomorrow.

The 1-2 Gophers lost to nationally ranked USC and were upset by New Mexico State before needing a blocked punt that was returned for a touchdown to defeat Miami (Ohio) last week.  “We are still a long way from being very good,” Kill said.

Gophers cornerback Michael Carter was a much anticipated Florida recruit when he signed with Minnesota in 2009.   He started six games his first two seasons but hasn’t played in the first three games this year.  Kill said there are no discipline problems with Carter and although he isn’t unhappy with him, “just maybe I expect more at this point in time.”

Although the Lions have lost 19 of the last 22 games against the Vikings since 2000, Detroit will be about a three point favorite on Sunday here.  Kevin Seifert from ESPN.com reports this is the first week since the Vikings started playing at the Metrodome (1982) that Detroit has been favored in Minneapolis.

Vikings offensive tackle Phil Loadholt and his fiancée Shannon have a son named Cameron born on September 6.

Rookie Vikings defensive tackle Christian Ballard played with former Cretin Derham-Hall star Broderick Binns at Iowa.  Ballard believes Binns, a defensive end, will be drafted by an NFL team next season and praises his friend’s work ethic.  A large wing span is another Binns asset and can help provide leverage on offensive players.  “He has the longest arms I’ve ever seen,” Ballard said.

Toby Gerhart had a 41-yard pass reception and rushed twice for 36 yards                 last week against the Bucs.  With a year’s NFL experience now, Gerhart is more confident about himself and comfortable in the Vikings’ system.  He said he didn’t “enjoy” last year that much.

Budget cuts at WCCO-TV mean that starting next month, part-time sports reporter Eric Nelson will no longer be working for the station.  Nelson also works for WCCO Radio.

Tomorrow afternoon’s Wild preseason game in Pittsburgh against the Penguins will be on the NHL Network.  The Wild plays its first home preseason game tonight versus Columbus.

Comments Welcome