David Shama's Minnesota Sports Headliners

Gophers Recruiting? Let’s Be Honest.

Posted on November 2, 2011November 27, 2011 by David Shama

Rivals.com ranks the Gophers 2012 football recruiting class last in the Big Ten. Is that a precursor of more losing seasons in Dinkytown? Well, that depends on whether your beer stein is half empty or half full.

Rivals lists 22 verbal commitments for the Gophers and only six of those players had offers from other BCS schools, according to local Rivals expert Zach Johnson. “They have a lot of solid commitments right now, but no one I think on paper that would excite a lot of people,” he told Sports Headliners.

The Gophers have nearly a full recruiting class already and more commitments than 10 other Big Ten schools, according to the Rivals website. That means there’s not much remaining potential for the Gophers to bolster their rankings by Rivals and others who evaluate college recruiting.

But Johnson, whose byline is seen on GopherIllustrated.com, pointed out that because many of the Gophers recruits committed early they didn’t position themselves to collect multiple offers from BCS schools. Mankato West quarterback Phil Nelson is an example of a player who could certainly have had more than the one offer from Minnesota. “I would want to count a kid like that,” Johnson said.

What Gophers fans can count on with Kill and his staff is a recruiting approach that won’t shoot for the moon trying to lure high profile four and five-star prospects. Kill and his assistants will trust their evaluation skills to identify talent they can develop into Big Ten winners.

“That’s what he’s going to have to do to build this program because right now ─ with the current status of the program ─ you’re not going to be able to lure in a lot of four-star recruits that have offers from the top teams in BCS conferences,” Johnson said.

Comments Welcome

Fans Focusing on QB Nelson Already

Posted on November 2, 2011November 27, 2011 by David Shama

Minnesota was 3-9 last season and 2-6 so far in 2011. Kill frequently reminds the fan base it’s going to take a few years to make the program a winner and that has fans looking at recruits including Nelson who has emerged as the poster boy of the 2012 class.

Johnson said Nelson is on pace to graduate from high school early and join some other 2012 recruits in spring practice with the Gophers. “I know Phil Nelson, they (the U coaches) love him,” Johnson said. “I think they think he can come in here and be a three or four year starter at quarterback.”

Johnson “wouldn’t be shocked” if Nelson was the Gophers’ No. 1 quarterback next season. That’s predicated not only on Nelson’s development but also junior starter MarQueis Gray’s faltering in Minnesota’s last four games this fall. The preferred option, Johnson said, is for Gray to be successful and Nelson to use 2012 as a redshirt season.

Blue Earth offensive tackle Jonah Pirsig is another publicized Gophers recruit from Minnesota. Johnson considers him “more of a project that you take time to develop on the offensive line.” Mississippi junior college running back James Gillum is the most recent commitment listed by Rivals. Johnson sees him as a complement to the power running of Gophers freshmen David Cobb and Donnell Kirkwood.

“I think Gillum will be a back they (the coaches) try to use to get into space,” Johnson said. “Be more of that third down back, but also bring some speed to the position. One thing the Gophers haven’t had in a long time is an explosive running back with that extra gear and I think they hope Gillum’s that guy.”

Among other recruits listed by Rivals, Johnson believes the Gophers coaches are high on North Carolina wide receiver Jamel Harbison. He also thinks Florida defensive back Dinero Moss might be able to “play right away.”

Comments Welcome

Worth Noting

Posted on November 2, 2011November 27, 2011 by David Shama

Lindy’s Sports College Basketball Magazine’s choice for “Most Entertaining” player in the Big Ten is Minnesota’s Rodney Williams. The 6-7 junior forward hasn’t approached his potential but his athleticism is eye-catching. In practice Williams has not only been in his usual role of small forward, but he has also played power forward.

Senior forward Trevor Mbakwe played like an All-Big Ten player last night in Minnesota’s opening exhibition game, a 71-58 win over Bemidji State. Mbakwe played hard and was an inside force scoring and rebounding for the Gophers, finishing with a double-double of 17 points and 11 rebounds.

Prep basketball authority Ken Lien emailed news that 6-foot-7 forward C.J. Neumann from Cretin-Derham Hall has committed to Wofford.

Wonder if anyone who sent a wedding gift last August is asking for a return after this week’s announcement that former Gophers ball hog Kris Humphries and Kim Kardashian plan to divorce?

When the WNBA draft lottery is held Thursday, November 10, the Lynx have the second best odds of winning the No. 1 pick. The lottery is for teams who didn’t make the playoffs but the WNBA champion Lynx have Washington’s draft pick ─ currently slotted at No. 2 ─ because of a trade earlier this year. The lottery determines the first four picks in the draft.

Iowa athletic director Gary Barta compared his 2010 hire of basketball coach Fran McCaffery with Minnesota’s decision to choose Jerry Kill as the new Gophers coach. Both coaches were program builders at lower level schools before coming to the Big Ten and Barta said it’s not always the “sexy hire” who is the best person for the job.

Barta, who played high school football for Burnsville, describes Iowa’s Kirk Ferentz as the “best” football coach in the country. Under Ferentz Iowa has only two losing seasons in the Big Ten since 2000.

Wherever Kill has coached, he’s made special teams a priority. The Gophers’ two wins this season have turned on a few big plays including a blocked punt returned for the decisive touchdown against Miami (Ohio) in September and an onside kickoff that set up the winning drive in last Saturday’s win over Iowa.

Talkative Vikings punter Chris Kluwe hosts the “Know Your Vikings” segment on the Mall of America Field video screen during home games. He includes a question for the interviewee like this: If a tree falls in the forest does it make a sound?

Rookie tight end Kyle Rudolph didn’t hesitate with an “of course not” correct answer to that question.

Christian Ponder said in the October 31 issue of Sports Illustrated that Green Bay’s Clay Mathews told him during the Vikings-Packers game in Minneapolis last month to stop running because he “wasn’t Tim Tebow.”

In the preseason MIAC women’s hockey coaches poll, Gustavus received nine of 10 first place votes. A 2012 Gusties league title would be the program’s eighth in a row.

The men’s hockey poll resulted in considerably more difference of opinion, with St. Thomas picked to finish first in the conference race. The Tommies received 60 points followed by Gustavus (52), Concordia (51) and Hamline (49).

Comments Welcome