Vikings – Page 5 – David Shama's Minnesota Sports Headliners

NFL Authority Not Touting Vikes Mullens as McCarthy Backup

Posted on March 3, 2025March 3, 2025 by David Shama

It appears likely the Vikings are moving on from Sam Darnold as their No. 1 quarterback and replacing him with J.J. McCarthy as the starter for the 2025 season. So, who will back up McCarthy?

Nick Mullens, the 29-year-old who backed up Darnold last year when McCarthy was injured and out for the season, has been with the Vikings since 2022, knows the offense and is a personable leader. But in his six-season NFL career, Mullens has thrown 31 interceptions in 34 games, including double-digit totals in two eight-game seasons starting for the 49ers.

“No, I don’t trust Nick Mullens,” a former executive with NFL teams told Sports Headliners. “I know he had a couple snaps last year and did okay, but we saw enough of him the year before to know that he’s a turnover machine (eight picks in 148 pass attempts).”

The source, asking that his name not be used, indicated the importance of a worthy backup is accentuated by McCarthy’s injury history as a rookie in 2024 who played in one preseason game before injuring his knee. He suggested it’s on the Vikings to find a higher-level talent with experience to be the No. 2 QB. Among names he mentioned were 27-year-old Daniel Jones who Minnesota acquired last fall and might re-sign in the offseason as a free agent.

The authority, who still follows the NFL closely including the Vikings, is okay with Mullens as No. 3 on the QB roster. He points out that Minnesota head coach Kevin O’Connell likes Jones and said that if he were in charge he would offer the former Giants 2019 first-round draft choice a two-year deal at $12.5 million.

Prior to joining the Vikings in late November, Jones completed 64.1 percent of his career passes for 14,582 yards, 70 touchdowns and 47 interceptions. A starter for 10 games with the Giants in 2024, he has 2,179 career rushing yards and 15 touchdowns on 399 carries.

Sam Darnold image courtesy of the Minnesota Vikings

The Vikings have until 4 p.m. Tuesday to franchise tag Darnold, if that’s their intent. The move might cost Minnesota about $40 million and it’s believed the Vikings would do so only if they thought they could trade him for a high future draft choice. If they can’t move Darnold, then Minnesota would be stuck with the $40 million, eating up perhaps two-thirds of the franchise’s salary cap room to sign other players.

Darnold resurrected his pro career in his initial season with Minnesota. The Sporting News and Professional Football Writers Association of America both named him league Comeback Player of the Year for his 2024 production that included career highs in several passing categories.

Darnold led the Vikings to a 14-3 regular season record but disappointed in the two biggest games of the year. With the NFC No. 1 seed in the playoffs at stake, Darnold and the Vikings lost in their regular season finale to the Lions and then failed to win in Minnesota’s opening playoff game against the Rams. In the Lions game he twice missed a wide-open Justin Jefferson in the end zone. He was a combined 43 of 81 passes in the two games and was sacked nine times by the Rams.

The way Darnold played in his last two games tempers enthusiasm and interest in the 27-year-old who until 2024 had been an NFL journeyman. “It was so disappointing how he played at the end,” the source said. “I mean, really just killed them (Vikings’ chances).

“That’s why I say how can you put big money into a guy if you can’t trust him to win a big game? And you got a young guy (McCarthy) you picked 10^th overall who you expect to be the future, and you got a coach who is a great quarterback coach.

“That’s why it all makes sense that it’s going to be turned over to McCarthy. I’ll be surprised if that’s not the case. And I expect some team to probably give Darnold a decent deal and I don’t think the Vikings are going to try to match that. It would make no sense unless they didn’t have faith in McCarthy, which I think they do.”

Could Darnold raise his game to be elite on the biggest of stages? “It’s possible because we didn’t think he’d get to what he did last year in the first 16 games.” the authority said. “But you invested in a first-round pick and you think that guy is special, which potentially I think he could be.

“And the one thing about McCarthy, in the big games (in college) he was clutch. National championship, playoffs.

“And that’s what Darold wasn’t was clutch at the end. So to me, you cut the cord. …”

It’s thought that Darnold will seek a multi-year deal as a free agent with any one of several teams, with perhaps the Raiders and Steelers the most likely of suitors. Would they be willing to pay $35 to $40 million per season?

The Vikings, with their own free agent needs, are likely to spend cap money on re-signing players like cornerback Byron Murphy Jr. And shopping in free agency for help in the interior offensive and defensive lines, and at cornerback.

O’Connell seems committed to McCarthy who he referred to last year as the “young franchise quarterback.” The 22-year-old, who was 27-1 as a starter at Michigan and has an ideal NFL QB physique at 6-foot-3 and about 220 pounds, apparently is successfully rehabbing from knee surgery. He likely impressed teammates and coaches last year in the spring and summer with his physical skills and leadership.

The authority thinks the Vikings have long had a plan to make McCarthy the starter in year two of his NFL career. The bigger issue now looks like who will be his backup.

Comments Welcome

Vikings Likely Know Answer on Key Sam Darnold Question

Posted on February 4, 2025February 4, 2025 by David Shama

Quarterback Sam Darnold resurrected his NFL career in his first season with the Vikings. The Sporting News and Professional Football Writers Association of America both named him league Comeback Player of the Year for his 2024 performance that included career highs in several passing categories.

Darnold led the Vikings to a 14-3 regular season record but wasn’t sharp in the two biggest games of the year. With the NFC No. 1 seed in the playoffs at stake, Darnold and the Vikings lost in their regular season finale to the Lions and then failed to win in Minnesota’s opening playoff game against the Rams. Darnold was a combined 43 of 81 passes in the two games and was sacked nine times by the Rams.

Head coach Kevin O’Connell and his staff convincingly showed the football world this fall their magic in creating elite quarterback play. The reality that Darnold struggled in his biggest games is mostly on him and his teammates, not the coaching staff.

What KOC and his helpers have likely decided by now is whether Darnold is a solid bet to be able to take the next potential step in his development—excelling in the biggest moments. Does he have the skills and mental makeup to lead the Vikings to the Super Bowl or at least the NFC title game in the near future?

The Vikings almost certainly have a good handle on what the ceiling is for the 27-year-old Darnold, a guy who for six pro seasons was a journeyman with other clubs.

Along with that comes the conundrum of whether J.J. McCarthy, the rookie last year who never saw the field because of his knee injury, is the better bet to take the franchise to championships. A 10-year-old knows building a Super Bowl contending team begins with a quarterback who is among the best in the NFL.

They have invested emotionally in McCarthy, the No. 10 draft choice in the first round in 2024. After McCarthy was hurt in the preseason, O’Connell referred to him as the “young franchise quarterback.”

If that is still KOC’s conviction, then the smart move is to franchise or transition tag Darnold for perhaps $40 million and trade him. There are at least a half dozen NFL teams looking for quarterbacks and the 2025 college draft is weak in QB prospects.

A trade could return player assets to the Vikings and allow the franchise to spend the $40 million upgrading talent at other positions and retaining their own free agents. Roster needs include the interior offensive and defensive lines and cornerback.

It could be a benefit that McCarthy missed his first year. He had the opportunity to learn the system while rehabbing from two knee procedures. He figures to be much more comfortable in the offense in 2025, if healthy.

If the Vikings let Darnold go and gamble on McCarthy, fingers will be crossed in Skol Country that the 22-year-old is ready in every way. If not, KOC will be looking for another bridge quarterback and trying to work his “magic” on a Darnold 2.0—e.g. Daniel Jones if he elects to stay with the team as a free agent starting next month.

Worth Noting

Daniel House, the college and pro football authority, told Sports Headliners defensive tackle is a deep and quality position in the April college draft. That could be good news for the Vikings who need help. Follow House on X @DanielHouseMN and on his Gophers and Vikings websites. https://gophersguru.com/ http://www.mnvikingscorner.com/

Running back is another position with quality and depth in the draft. Iowa’s Kaleb Johnson, who was troublesome to the Gophers and others in the Big Ten, could certainly be available to the Vikings at No. 24 in the first round or after Day 1. The Vikings need an explosive runner as a successor to 30-year-old Aaron Jones.

Minnesota Breakfast attendees in Naples, Florida heard from first-year University of Minnesota president Rebecca Cunningham last Friday. Minneapolis-based attorney and journalist Marshall Tanick reported via email Dr. Cunningham “primarily focused on health sciences and technology challenges the University faces. But she touched upon Gopher athletics, telling the group of Minnesota expatriates and seasonal visitors that she and athletic Director Mark Coyle are ‘committed to having a competitive Big Ten program.’” She also praised the record 3.4 GPA compiled by U athletes last semester.

The expectation is that the drawn-out arbitration process to determine majority ownership of the Timberwolves and Lynx will conclude any day now. If the Marc Lore and Alex Rodriguez group wins the litigation with long-time owner Glen Taylor, they still must get no less than 75 percent approval from the NBA Board of Governors.

Based on NBAstore.com data through the first half of the NBA season the Warriors’ Steph Curry had the top selling jersey, while the Wolves’ Anthony Edwards ranked No. 6.

The Timberwolves, trying to establish favorable seeding for the Western Conference playoffs later this year, are in the midst of a five-game homestand. They will also have a five-game home schedule March 1-8. Both slates will be significant in determining the team’s final record.

After last night’s loss to the Kings at Target Center the Wolves are 0-2 on the homestand that began Saturday night in a loss to the lowly Wizards. Coming up are games with the Bulls, Rockets and Trail Blazers.

The Wolves, 27-23, are only 12-12 in home games, while their road record is 15-11.

The Wild, 31-18-4 is 20-6-3 on the road and inexplicably 11-12-1 at Xcel Energy Center.

The Wild, who played nine road games in January, have their longest home schedule with seven games March 9-22. The month has Minnesota playing nine games at the Xcel, the most in any month this season.

If there is a men’s basketball head coaching vacancy at Minnesota or Iowa in the near future, it would be preposterous for hiring authorities to not have John Tauer on the short list of candidates who interest them. A Division III national champion at St. Thomas, Tauer has superbly guided the Tommies to Division I competition, and his 2025 team is in first place in the Summit League with an 8-1 record (18-6 overall).

The NCAA Men’s Basketball Net Rankings have Iowa No. 64, Minnesota No. 101 and St. Thomas No. 103.

With a deadline of February 27, the U Athletic Department is offering new purchasers of football season tickets two complimentary tickets to both a men’s and women’s Gopher home basketball game.

A concerning trend has developed with the U football staff. Offensive coordinator Kirk Ciarrocca left for Rutgers after the 2022 season and defensive coordinator Joe Rossi departed for Michigan State following 2023. Rossi’s replacement, Corey Hetherman, recently left for Miami and this week comes news that defensive line coach Winston DeLattiboudere is headed to the NFL Cardinals.

All left for more money, including Ciarrocca who reportedly has received an extension that will pay him $2 million in 2027. Head coach P.J. Fleck attracts quality assistants but it’s difficult to retain them when the salary pool for his staff is at or near the bottom of the 18-member Big Ten Conference.

DeLattiboudere, who becomes the Arizona defensive line coach, played with Cardinals defensive coordinator Nick Rallis, the Edina native, when the two were Gophers. Rallis was named defensive coordinator in 2023.

Perhaps the best clinic in the country for high school football coaches, the 2025 MFCA Clinic will be held March 27-29, with headquarters at the DoubleTree Park Place in St. Louis Park. Minnesota Football Coaches Association secretary-treasurer Jim Dotseth reported over 800 registrants so far. https://www.mnfootballcoaches.com/page/show/2279758-mfca-clinic-information

Almost 500 copies of The Book of Piv were sold on Amazon during a five-week period. The entertaining new book offers storytelling by Minneapolis native Jay Pivec, now retired but a well-traveled basketball coach who is in the NJCAA Coaches Association Hall of Fame.

Lily Hubanks, a senior from Madison, Wisconsin, and Amae-Kam Magruder, a sophomore from Anchorage, Alaska, are standouts for the St. Olaf women’s Nordic ski team. They recently represented the United States in the 2025 FISU Winter World University Games in Italy.

Hubanks and Magruder competed in five events as part of the four-member cross country teams for the U.S. It’s believed they are the first females from a Minnesota college to be on American teams in the Winter World University games.

2 comments

Twins President: ‘We’re Better Than What The Public Thinks’

Posted on January 30, 2025January 30, 2025 by David Shama

The Twins want a bounce-back season in 2025, and it’s been suggested the club has the potential to not only win the American League Central Division but also have the best roster.

“I agree with that,” club president Dave St. Peter said yesterday. “We’re better than what the public thinks we are right now. And I recognize…it’s rooted in frustration with payroll, and the fact that we haven’t added (players) to the team. But when you look at the core roster, and particularly the pitching—assuming we stay healthy throughout the roster—we’re going to have a really quality baseball team.

“And again, we have to stay healthy. I think that’s going to be critical for our best players to be on the diamond, (Carlos) Correa, (Byron) Buxton, (Royce) Lewis. And assuming they are, I like our chances to not only win the division but challenge in the month of October (postseason).”

Shortstop Correa, center fielder Buxton and right fielder Matt Wallner are on the short list of the better MLB players at their positions. If Lewis hadn’t experienced a slide toward the end of last season he would be in that company at third base.

Lewis, a .300 hitter prior to last year when he slumped to .233, was frustrated late in the year with not only his hitting but also reportedly the experiment to have him play second base. St. Peter told Sports Headliners Lewis, 25, will play third base in spring training, but didn’t rule out games at second during the season.

St. Peter sees the challenge of last season as being a positive for Lewis’ development. An experience that contributes to his growth and improvement. “…I think we’re seeing that out of Royce, and we believe Royce is really positioned to bounce back in a big way from what we saw at the conclusion of the 2024 season.”

Led by executive Derek Falvey, the Twins are looking for potential opportunities to improve the roster via trades or free agent signings. St. Peter said because of pitching’s importance that category is always a priority, and he mentioned first base as a position the club might bolster.

It’s been suggested a right-handed hitting center fielder to back up Buxton could be a need, too. St. Peter acknowledged that but also said reserve right-handed hitting Austin Martin has “all the tools” and will have an opportunity in spring training to show what he can do in center.

“We have good players,” St. Peter said. “We like our roster. We think we’re in a really good, interesting spot. This is an exciting time I still believe to be a Twins fan. There’s a lot of familiarity and stability within this roster. So, we just can’t wait to get started.”

The Twins began and finished the season poorly in 2024. The culprit in the closing weeks was lack of run production as Minnesota lost eight of its last 10 games and finished with an 82-80 record after winning the division in 2023.

From the new hitting coach Matt Borgschulte and manager Rocco Baldelli there will be emphasis in spring training to have players better prepared at the plate. The focus on improved offense is expected to include better situational hitting to advance runners and score runs.

Minnesota started last season 7-13. St. Peter said in spring training there will be a “mindset” and intensity to achieve a winning record in April. Urgency is expected to be conveyed in spring training that starts next month in Fort Myers.

Worth Noting

St. Peter said there is no “definitive timetable” on the sale of the franchise but there is significant interest from potential buyers. “That should not surprise anybody,” he said. “This is a great market. We have a world-class ballpark. Really solid organization.

“The baseball organization is in a really good spot with a really competitive major league team in a very winnable division. So, all that leads up to a lot of interest and the reality that this is a gem of a franchise.”

February 11 is the first day fans can sign up to watch Twins games via streaming. The cost is $99.99 for the whole season, or $19.99 monthly.

St. Peter is “highly confident” there will soon be an announcement of what channels to watch games on via cable and satellite. Between streaming and cable/satellite he thinks 10-12 spring training games will be available for viewing.

He added there is also the possibility of some games being available free via over-the-air broadcasting.

Minnesota Breakfast attendees in Naples, Florida recently heard from Minnesota Wild newsmakers Bill Guerin and Matt Majka. Guerin, the Wild’s GM, praised John Hynes for helping the team get off to a “strong start” during his first full season while noting the head coach’s commitment to “detail” in preseason training and practice sessions.

While bemoaning “another season filled with injuries” to at least a half-dozen key players, Guerin said the team has a “solid foundation” with young players on the squad and top prospects in the farm system. The Wild, who missed the playoffs last season, has one of the NHL’s top point totals with 64 but is only 4-6 in the last 10 games.

CEO Majka, who’s been with the franchise since its inception, previewed proposed renovations to the 25-year-old Xcel Energy Center. Even though the facility is in good shape, Majka said, upgrading is a “top priority” to keep the aging facility competitive with other venues, particularly Target Center in downtown Minneapolis, as well as to serve the team’s “terrific fan base.”

The 61-year-old Minnesota Breakfast group was started by Minnesota snowbirds and transplants. In winter months, the group hears weekly from prominent speakers. University of Minnesota president Rebecca Cunningham is the scheduled speaker this Friday. https://mnbreakfast.org/schedule/?yr=2025

Reporting from Naples on much of the above via email was Marshall Tanick, the prominent Minneapolis-based attorney who also writes articles for Minnesota and Florida publications.

Tanick offered the following observations about the NFL’s NFC North Division in 2024:

“All season long we were told that the NFC North —the old Black & Blue (B & B) Division—was the best in the NFL—based upon the records of the top three teams: Lions, Vikings, Packers.

“Seeing how the trio performed in the playoffs—each blowing their games by double digit scores—that evaluation needs revision, huh?

“In fact, the B & B has not had a team in the Super Bowl since the Packers won in 2011. In the meantime, every other division in the NFL, except the AFC South (Jacksonville, Houston, Indianapolis, and Tennessee), has had at least one team make it that far. …

“Could it be that the Black and Blue division is over-rated?”

Denny Schulstad, the 80-year-old former Minneapolis City Council leader and retired Air Force Brigadier General, winters in Arizona where he plays tennis “4-6 times each week.”

2 comments